Caitlin O’Connor Shares the Special Moment She Realized Joe Manganiello Was Her Perfect Match

Joe Manganiello’s Fiancée Caitlin O’Connor Reveals the Moment She Knew He Was ‘The One’ (Exclusive).
Credit:

Courtesy Caitlin O’Connor

Caitlin O’Connor Shares Heartfelt Moment with Joe Manganiello

Caitlin O’Connor recently opened up about the pivotal moment she realized that Joe Manganiello was "the one." The couple, who first sparked dating rumors in 2023, became engaged in October and have since relocated to Pittsburgh, their hometown.

Reflecting on her relationship, O’Connor, 36, described the intense chemistry she shares with Manganiello, 48. Speaking to PEOPLE, she recounted an intimate moment that solidified her feelings during a crowded outing. “We were holding hands in a crowd rushing by us and someone tried to cut through, attempting to break our hold,” she said. “Joe protected that hand-hold and wouldn’t let the person cross in between us, and that is when I knew he was the one!"

The couple has made the transition from Los Angeles to Mount Lebanon, Pittsburgh, a move O’Connor confirmed was filled with joy. Both hail from the area and are excited to be home for the holiday season. "It’s beautiful to be back home together," she stated, adding that they cherish the similarities in their upbringing.

Describing their new neighborhood, O’Connor remarked, "It’s like a postcard here. I’ve never been in a more beautiful neighborhood in Pittsburgh. And it’s just idyllic." She also shared her admiration for Manganiello, highlighting a moment when she watched him shovel their snowy driveway for hours, calling it “the hottest thing I’ve ever seen.”

O’Connor expressed anticipation for their upcoming family celebration during the holidays, noting that their families will join them in Pittsburgh. The couple has already begun creating their own holiday traditions. "Joe and I have been sort of on a world tour since we met,” O’Connor explained. “We’ve traveled to over 70 cities in the last two years and collected ornaments from every place we’ve visited."

Since acknowledging their relationship in December 2023, O’Connor has emphasized the depth of their bond, with sources noting that Manganiello treats her “like a queen.” Their shared love for each other continues to flourish as they navigate this exciting new chapter in their lives.